100 Views

January 13 marks turning point or possible end of New Jersey sportsbetting fight

The United States Supreme Court is scheduled to hold conference on New Jersey‘s fight to have their sports betting case heard on January 13. If at least four of the current eight justices decide to hear the case, parties and the public should know by January 17 and the case would go to the SCOTUS calendar for 2017. Not many options beyond waiting for another state in another circuit to beat sports betting opponents exist if the court refuses to hear the case next month.

How the justices determine whether to hear the case or not will likely depend on their view of the United States Constitution. If heard, the case could set precedence in far-reaching areas of law as it rests on core principles of state’s rights, federalism, and interstate commerce.

New Jersey and the NJ Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Association filed briefs Wednesday in response to professional sports leagues filings earlier asking the court not to hear the state’s appeal. The parties are appealing a Third Circuit Court en banc panel’s decision this summer that determined New Jersey’s attempt to partially repeal sports betting laws applying to casinos and racetracks, left them in effect for any other venue in the state – effectively still legalizing them in violation of the 1992 Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act.

The appealing parties (joined by Mississippi, West Virginia, Arizona, Louisiana, and Wisconsin) say that Congress, while able to regulate citizens, may not “require the states to govern by Congress’ instruction.”

In his brief to the court, Governor Chris Christie argued that “Congress lacks the power to compel a State to prohibit acts under its own state laws. If all a State does is narrow its own state-law prohibitions, there is nothing Congress constitutionally may preempt.”

In the Horsemen’s separate brief the NJTHA argued that “PASPA regulates the content of state law without any federal rule governing commerce as its foundation,” whereas federal statutes that preempt state law do so as a consequence of the creation of some federal rule governing commerce.

In a nutshell, the federal government is or is not allowed to force a state to repeal or reinstate their own laws.

In 1992 the PASPA barred all but four states from allowing sports betting. Those states already had existing laws on the books authorizing the practice to one degree or another. New Jersey failed to authorize sports betting before the federal law took effect. After a 2012 law allowing sports betting in the state was struck down in 2012, Governor Christie signed a law into effect repealing the state’s prohibition of betting at casinos and racetracks in a move that led to the current case before the court.

That law was also tossed by a federal judge in New Jersey as well as at a full hearing before all 12 active judges of the circuit court of appeals in Pennsylvania. Optimism lit up the sports betting media when the court decided that the issue was too complicated to be heard by only three judges and went to the en banc panel.

New Jersey pols have long fought to legalize sports betting in the state as a way to raise revenues and help the struggling Atlantic City casino industry. Currently, only Borgata has a race book and no legal venues in the state offer sports books. The American Gaming Association (AGA) estimates that at least $150 billion a year is wagered illegally on sports betting in the United States which provides revenues to organized crime rather than to states as it would in a well-regulated market.

January 13 marks turning point or possible end of New Jersey sportsbetting fight was last modified: December 29th, 2016 by Lars Jones


Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox!

Don't worry, we don't spam

Latest Posts

Proponents of casino gaming and pari-mutuel wagering in Georgia join forces
horse racing
401 views
horse racing
401 views

Proponents of casino gaming and pari-mutuel wagering in Georgia join forces

Editor - October 1, 2017

2017 may be the year that the state of Georgia finally legalizes casino gaming and pari-mutuel racing. Proponents of both activities are now working together in the…

Britain’s Chelmsford racecourse approved for city’s first casino
horse racing
384 views
horse racing
384 views

Britain’s Chelmsford racecourse approved for city’s first casino

Editor - September 29, 2017

Thoroughbred horse racing venue, Chelmsford City Racecourse, located in Essex, England, has been given the green light to open an all-night casino, according to EssexLive. The venue,…

CasinoCoin being re-launched following takeover
tech
381 views
tech
381 views

CasinoCoin being re-launched following takeover

Editor - September 27, 2017

In the world of online gambling, the CasinoCoin open-source peer-to-peer crypto-currency has been taken over by the newly-established Double C Foundation and re-launched with the aim of…

Imperial Pacific seeks amendment to casino license agreement
new hotels
448 views
new hotels
448 views

Imperial Pacific seeks amendment to casino license agreement

Editor - September 27, 2017

After Typhoon Soudelor (Hanna) the strongest tropical cyclone of the 2015 Pacific typhoon season took its toll on the early construction of Imperial Pacific’s Phase I casino resort…

Kansas Crossing Casino to begin soft opening last week of March
new hotels
315 views
new hotels
315 views

Kansas Crossing Casino to begin soft opening last week of March

Editor - September 27, 2017

While keeping with their latest Grand Opening date of April 8, 2017, Kansas Crossing Casino has now announced that special guests will receive ‘sneak peeks’ throughout the…

Genting Group receives initial approval for downtown Miami hotel proposal
new hotels
385 views
new hotels
385 views

Genting Group receives initial approval for downtown Miami hotel proposal

Editor - September 27, 2017

In southern Florida, global casino operator Genting Group reportedly won unanimous support from an influential Miami-Dade County committee last week for its plan to build a 300-room…

Amaya appoints new Chief Technology Officer
tech
313 views
tech
313 views

Amaya appoints new Chief Technology Officer

Editor - September 27, 2017

Leading provider of technology-based products and services, Amaya Inc. (NASDAQ: AYA ), announced Wednesday that it has appointed former technology consultant for Partis Solutions, Jerry Bowskill, as its…

del Lago Resort & Casino to debut new slot technology this weekend
tech
273 views
tech
273 views

del Lago Resort & Casino to debut new slot technology this weekend

Editor - September 27, 2017

The del Lago Resort & Casino in upstate New York is preparing to debut new technology this weekend with an interactive slot tournament on the schedule for this Saturday.…

BetTracker mobile sportsbetting app rolled out across Great Britain
tech
259 views
tech
259 views

BetTracker mobile sportsbetting app rolled out across Great Britain

Editor - September 27, 2017

Ahead of next month’s start to the domestic football season in the United Kingdom, gambling software innovator Playtech has announced that the BetTracker product from its Playtech…

Quickspin bringing Second Strike to Ladbrokes retail estate
tech
330 views
tech
330 views

Quickspin bringing Second Strike to Ladbrokes retail estate

Editor - September 27, 2017

Online gambling software innovator Playtech has announced that its Quickspin video slot development subsidiary has signed a deal to introduce its very own Second Strike game onto…